Paul Thompson

All firms are co-operatives? That can’t be right…
When I first started studying co-operatives as a graduate student, the first article I read was a piece provocatively titled “All firms are cooperatives – and so are governments.” Its author, Yale law professor Henry Hansmann, claimed exactly what you would expect from the title: that investor-owned businesses were no different in their structure than co-operatives.
He writes:
In fact, nearly all privately owned firms are cooperatives. This includes, in particular, the conventional investor-owned firm – the business corporation, or joint stock company – that we are accustomed to labelling ‘capitalist.’ Such firms are simply a subset of producer cooperatives that we might call ‘capital cooperatives.’ They are owned collectively by the persons who supply capital to the organization, with an individual owner’s share in both profits and voting rights determined by the amount of capital they have contributed (2014, p. 2).
Capital Co-operative? Excuse me? If Amazon and Walmart are co-operatives, then why did I spend my tuition on a course about co-operatives? I could have just taken a class on corporations… It took me most of the following semester to realize that Hansmann glosses over some small details that make a world of difference.
So what are those details and why do they matter? Well, there are a lot of those details. At least a semester’s worth; even enough for a lifetime of research and publication. Maybe more. But let’s begin with the details tied to the most vital organ of an organization’s anatomy: governance.
Hansmann isn’t entirely wrong about the similarities between co-ops and investor-owned businesses. The governance structure of any enterprise – co-operative or otherwise – will have the same fundamental structure comprised of three essential parts:
- An owner or owners. In most corporations, the owners will be the shareholders. In most co-operatives, the owners are the members.
- A group that makes decisions on behalf of the owners by representing their interests. In most organizations, this is a board of directors or a board of governors.
- A manager who runs the organization according to the instructions of the board. This is usually a chief executive officer or general manager.
No matter how large or small an organization, it will always have these three governance roles. In some organizations, the same person can occupy multiple roles. However, all three will exist in any kind of enterprise, from small mom-and-pop stores to large multinational corporations.

Co-ops aren’t just organizations. They are a movement with a history.
So if a co-operative has the same parts as an investor-owned company, how is its governance different, and why is it worth studying this difference? Let’s look at two critical differences between co-operative and corporate governance.
- Democratic member control. Democratic member control is one of the seven principles included in the ICA’s statement on the co-operative identity. This means that co-op members ultimately make decisions about the organization through their voting, often at an annual general meeting. Stockholders of a corporation will also make decisions through voting. The difference is how votes are allocated.
In a stock corporation, votes are allocated based on the amount invested – anyone who has invested more than half of the total capital in the corporation can effectively out-vote all the other investors. Most co-operatives, on the other hand, are run on the principle of “one-member, one-vote.” This means voting power is based on your involvement as a member, not the amount of money you have invested. This seemingly subtle governance detail will mean a fundamentally different way of controlling the business and making decisions.
- Self-help and self-responsibility. These two values are the first listed among the six co-operative values in the statement on the co-operative identity. They have been present from the earliest beginnings of the co-op movement. Co-ops are about more than creating wealth for investors. They are about people solving problems for themselves, providing themselves with services such as electricity, or buying affordable or otherwise unattainable products, or creating secure employment. Co-ops aim to meet the economic, social, and cultural needs of a community.
Because co-ops are about self-help, they sometimes lack certain kinds of expertise. A board of directors made up of members from a small rural community will make decisions differently than a corporate board made up of highly compensated business experts. Because co-op boardrooms are filled by member-owners, they have to take special care in how they make decisions, and how they navigate their relationship with management, who will often have more expertise in running a business.
Some larger co-operatives, particularly in finance and retail, are starting to seek out expert directors, creating boards that look more like those of investor-owned firms. This is a controversial practice. Many co-op members are asking how their organization can balance the expertise needed to succeed in highly competitive markets with the longstanding “do it ourselves” mentality of the co-op movement and the desire to remain connected to the broad sweep of owners.
We discuss these issues in depth in our free online course “Governance in Co-operatives,” running from January 21st-March 4th on the Canvas network. This course will look at the principles of co-operative governance through the lens of in-depth case studies of real-world co-operatives. These case studies will focus on co-ops that have grappled with governance challenges that are unique to the co-operative structure.
By examining how these co-ops have succeeded or failed, we hope to show how – contrary to Henry Hanssman’s argument – co-operatives are a fundamentally different kind of organization that requires a fundamentally different approach to governance.
To sign up for Governance in Co-operatives, click here
For more information about the course, email governance.course@usask.ca

Paul Thompson, Knowledge Mobilization Officer, Centre for the Study of Co-operatives, University of Saskatchewan
Pingback: Connecting Co-operators | Contemplating Co-ops
Thank you so much. At last, I found an article which I am looking for quite
a long time. I hope that it will help me too.
Best regards,
Dinesen Raahauge
Pingback: college essay writing service reviews
Pingback: help in essay writing
Pingback: urgent custom essays
Pingback: best rated essay writing service
Pingback: dissertation writing fellowships
Pingback: phd online
Pingback: buy a research paper online
Pingback: can you write my paper for me
Pingback: how do i write a thesis
Pingback: what can i take to enhance cialis
Pingback: cialis pills
Pingback: cialis for sale
Pingback: cialis dosage
Pingback: where can i buy viagra
Pingback: pills like viagra over the counter
Pingback: cialis vs viagra
Pingback: buy viagra online
Pingback: canadian pharmacy uk delivery
Pingback: Benemid
Pingback: online pharmacy canada
Pingback: Kamagra Polo
Pingback: prescription online
Pingback: viagra
Pingback: cialis cheap
Pingback: cialis with dapoxetine review
Pingback: levitra or cialis which is better
Pingback: generic cialis 30 pills 20mg
Pingback: safest and most reliable pharmacy to buy cialis
Pingback: how much does viagra cost with out insurance
Pingback: cialis effetti collaterali
tadalafil daily use: http://tadalafilonline20.com/ tadalafil generic
generic tadalafil tadalafil online 20
tadalafil online 20
meds online without doctor prescription generic pills
buy prescription drugs online without usa pharmacy india
india pharmacy mail order india pharmacy drugs
medications without a doctor’s prescription: https://genericwdp.com/ buying prescription drugs from canada
where to buy viagra online price of viagra
buy real viagra online
viagra from canada best over the counter viagra
cheap viagra online
buying viagra online best place to buy viagra online
how much is viagra
viagra amazon cheap viagra online
where to buy viagra online
order viagra online over the counter viagra
viagra discount
best place to buy viagra online mexican viagra
generic viagra walmart
best place to buy generic viagra online best place to buy viagra online
where to buy viagra
viagra from india viagra without a doctor prescription
cost of viagra
viagra over the counter walmart viagra over the counter
viagra from india
finasteride 5 mg cheap propecia
canadian valtrex otc valtrex price south africa
ed solutions
diflucan pill uk diflucan 1140
price of viagra https://viagrapills100.com/ viagra discount
best place to buy viagra online https://viagrapills100.com/ when will viagra be generic
viagra from canada https://viagrapills100.com/ when will viagra be generic
cratosslot casino https://www.cratoswins.com/
cheap viagra online https://viagrapills100.com/ viagra cost
viagra price https://viagrapills100.com/ price of viagra
buy viagra online usa https://viagrapills100.com/ viagra cost
Buy essay papers online essayhelpof.com
cheap ed pills from canada ed pills online
order ed pills
I need help writing a thesis https://thesisacloud.com/ phd
thesis defense
buy ed pills from canada cheap ed pills in mexico
buy ed pills
buy ed drugs buy ed drugs
buy ed pills
Best custom essay service essaywriteris.com
custom essay services
muse ed drug order ed pills
cheap ed pills
Dissertation software https://dissertationahelp.com/ writing my dissertation
where can i get zithromax over the counter: cheap zithromax – zithromax cost australia
http://zithromaxst.com/# buy zithromax without presc
Pingback: professional thesis writing service
hydroxychloroquine sulfate australia: generic for hydroxychloroquine 200 mg – hydroxychloroquine 5 mg
https://hydroxychloroquinest.com/# hydroxychloroquine 90 mg
Custom college essay customessayin.com great essay
writers
prednisone 20 mg generic: buy prednisone online – 50 mg prednisone canada pharmacy
zithromax tablets: cheap zithromax – zithromax prescription in canada
http://gabapentinst.com/# 300 mg neurontin
Write my essay service https://essaywritera.com/ essay about community
service
https://zithromaxproff.com/# buy zithromax
buy azithromycin zithromax
http://zithromaxproff.com/# buy zithromax 500mg online
zithromax 250mg
Phd dissertations dissertationxyz.com
dissertation help literature review
http://zithromaxproff.com/# zithromax 500 mg for sale
zithromax price south africa
http://zithromaxproff.com/# zithromax 500 tablet
how much is zithromax 250 mg
Hmm is anyone else having problems with the pictures on this blog loading?
I’m trying to determine if its a problem on my end or if it’s the blog.
Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.
Quality custom essay write my essay for money essay writer
Write my college paper paper writing service college college papers writing service
order erythromycin: buy tetracycline generic
ketoconazole price
buy clindamycin generic: buy omnicef generic
order cefixime online
Cialis paypal bezahlen cialis canada and paypal köpä
cialis
buy cleocin: order ceftin online
order flagyl
flagyl generic: tetracycline generic
buy vantin
Viagra click here info buy cialis http://www.cialcenter.com buy cialis online overnight
Supreme suppliers cialis http://www.newcialed.com cialis omline
all generic meds from india: online indian pharmacies india pharmacy drugs
meds from india: united pharmacy india india pharmacy
chatterbate login
alprostadil penile suppository price https://alprostadildrugs.com/ muse alprostadil suppository
tadalafil 30 mg https://elitadalafill.com/ generic tadalafil 40 mg
india pharmacies online: india pharmacy mail order buy prescriptions from india pharmacy
vardenafil vs tadalafil https://vegavardenafil.com/ vardenafil dosage maximum
usa pharmacy india: india pharmacies online buy prescriptions from india pharmacy
Canadian pharmacy generic viagra pharmcanadayou.com legit online pharmacy
viagra pills: cialis pills cialis pills
viagra pills: viagra pills online best erectile dysfunction pills review
sildenafil citrate tablets ip 100 mg https://eunicesildenafilcitrate.com/ purchase sildenafil 20 mg
Everything is very open with a precise explanation of
the issues. It was definitely informative. Your website is extremely helpful.
Many thanks for sharing! 0mniartist asmr
cialis pills online: cialis pills online best erectile dysfunction pills
viagra pills: cialis pills ed pills for sale
Canadian drug stores online http://www.interpharmnew.com no prior prescription required pharmacy
viagra cost per pill buy viagra online without prescription viagra without a prescription
viagra cheap buy viagra online without prescription viagra without a doctor prescription
viagra no prescription viagra without a doctor prescription no prescription viagra
Order cialis india http://www.selectioncial.com cheap
generic cialis canada
generic name for viagra viagra prescription viagra without a doctor prescription usa
http://doxycyclinest.com/# doxycycline without prescription
http://diflucanst.com/# diflucan 150 tab
Tadalafil alternative buy tadalafil online canada tadalafil no prescription
https://clomidst.com/# clomid capsules 50mg
http://amoxilst.com/# buy amoxicillin without prescription
free single chat
single women dating
https://clomidst.com/# clomid order online
http://doxycyclinest.com/# doxycycline pills
https://diflucanst.com/# diflucan online australia
Sweѕet bⅼog! І found it while brоwwing on Yahoo News.
Do you have any tipss on how tto get listd in Yahoo News?
I’ve Ƅeedn trdying for a while but I never ѕeem to get thеre!
Thank you
Stop by my websitе; online payday loans canada
online pharmacies
http://amoxilst.com/# buy amoxicillin online without prescription
metformin 228: metformin – can i buy metformin over the counter in uk
where to buy metformin online: cheap metformin – buy metformin 1000 mg online
metformin no prescription: buy metformin online – can i order metformin online
lasix 100 mg tablet: lasix generic name – lasix 100 mg tablet
lasix 100 mg tablet: buy furosemide online – furosemide 40mg
metformin online usa: buy metformin online – metformin tablet cost
top rated ed pills: buy erection pills – medicine for erectile
propecia cost: buy finasteride – finesterude no prescription
cheapest propecia for sale