Power Struggle: Rural Electrification in Alberta

Danielle Potter

Source: Website of the Rocky Rural Electrification Association (http://www.rockyrea.com/about/history)



In his Fredeen Scholarship seminar, Eric Neudorf outlined how Alberta’s private power companies in the 1940s were able to change the regulatory landscape in a way that profoundly disadvantaged the rural electrical associations, with the result that today they are having difficulty surviving. How did this happen?

To understand this story, it is necessary to go back to the 1940s and recall the demand that was emerging in both the United States and Canada for rural electrification. Although electrical power had been provided to large urban areas and to rural areas close to the main power lines, most rural areas were not being served. The cost to provide this service was significant. The question facing governments of the day was, “Who would provide and pay for this service?”

In Alberta, the Alberta Power Commission suggested public ownership and proposed that the assets of the investor-owned utilities (IOUs) be combined to create a provincial utility that would supply the province. The fees from the private and municipal power authorities would be used to offset the costs of rural electrification.

The IOUs did not want a publicly owned utility, and they were not interested in distributing power to farms — the low population density in rural areas meant delivery costs were large and revenue potential was small.

As a result of a trip to the United States, where rural electric co-ops had been introduced and appeared to be working, the IOUs became advocates for a co-operative solution to rural electrification in Alberta. They knew it would benefit them if they encouraged farmers to invest in, build, and own their own lines. Since the farmers desired immediate electricity for their homes, they agreed that co-ops seemed to be the best option and began to form Rural Electrification Associations (REAs).

Source: Website of the Rocky Rural Electrification Association (http://www.rockyrea.com/about/history)



While REAs were being built, the Alberta government (the Social Credit Party) was still struggling with the key policy decision — should power generation and transmission be publicly owned, as the Power Commission had suggested, or should it be privately owned? This question was put to a plebiscite in 1948, and Alberta residents narrowly voted in favour of the private option. With the question settled, the government continued what the private electric companies had already been promoting — encouraging the formation of REAs.

The first Rural Electrical Association was formed in 1947, and by 1951, there were 356 REAs operating. They were, and still are, governed under the Rural Utilities Act. When the Act was created, the government gave the private power companies the opportunity to help draft it, which allowed them to structure the Act in their favour. The following four regulatory conditions have made it difficult for the REAs to compete:

  • The Act prevents Alberta electricity co-operatives from expanding outside of their specified sphere. This means they are unable to serve nonfarm customers. In particular, the REAs have not been able to service the oilfields that developed in rural areas. In addition, the customer definition in the Act refers to agriculture farms, which prevents the REAs from servicing some of their original customers when farmers expanded or diversified. For example, REAs are not allowed to provide power for more intensive farming operations such as feedlots, greenhouses, and dairies.
  • The Act enables private electric companies to rent REA grids at cost to provide electricity to towns and industrial sites — grids that were built and are owned by the REA members.
  • REAs are required to maintain a large reserve fund financed by monthly member fees. The fund covers the cost of upgrades and maintenance, which are decided on by the IOUs. The need to sustain this reserve fund makes it challenging for REAs to raise the capital required to grow and expand.
  • REAs cannot make changes to bylaws without the approval of the Act’s director, who is appointed by the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development. This requirement means political factors often play a role in the approvals — e.g., it gives interest groups such as the IOUs the ability to influence bylaw changes that inhibit the REAs’ strategic options. REAs have been stopped from restructuring their shares to capitalize new projects, and they have been prevented from enacting bylaws that would protect their organizations against demutualization.

Demutualization is the conversion of a co-operative, credit union, or mutual into an alternative organizational form. It typically involves the transfer to private investors of the assets that have been built up over the years in the co-operative (click here for a recent report on demutualization by Murray Fulton and Jean-Pierre Girard). Current REA members face two significant incentives to demutualize: they will receive a substantial payout from the sale of their assets; and the regulatory landscape has profound disadvantages for their co-operatives.

This is the key reason for the disappearance of rural electric co-operatives in Alberta. Even though they played a critical role in establishing the provincial electricity grid, the REAs have experienced a long, slow decline. As of January 2016, out of the 398 original REAs, 255 have sold their assets to private electric companies, while the remaining 143 have amalgamated to the point that only 38 REAs remain. Of these, two more have voted to demutualize and sell their assets.

Danielle Potter is a communications specialist at the Centre for the Study of Co-operatives

Unless changes are made to the regulatory environment, more REAs will decide to demutualize. While such changes are not impossible, they are unlikely, given the substantial power and influence the IOUs have exerted historically in the Alberta power sector.


If you find our blog useful, please add our link to your website.

172 thoughts on “Power Struggle: Rural Electrification in Alberta

  1. Pingback: What co-ops can teach you about rural life | Co-operatives FirstCo-operatives First

  2. Instagram da takipçi satın almak kadar Beğeni satın al için de biraz araştırma yapmalısınız.

    Çünki 10binlerce takipçisi olan kişilerin beğenileri de fazla
    olmalıdır, Beğenilerinizi gören herkes size hayranlık duyacaklardır bu sebepten beğeni paketlerini inceleyebilir
    Kendinize uygun instagram beğeni paketini seçerek satın alın

  3. Türkiye de bir çok kullanıcının istemekte olduğu üstelik Türkiyenin heryerinde yoğun bir ilginin söz hususu bulunduğu hizmetlerdendir.

    Instagram platformlarına ilginin yükselmesi ile beraber İnstagram da
    en mühim seçeneklerden biri durumuna gelmiştir.
    Bu bağlamda takipçi miktarını yükselterek tesir oranını çoğaltmak isteyen pek çok şahıs bulunmaktadır.

    Sizde Türkiye de ki bu ünlü olan yada olmak isteyen kişiler
    gibi hemen instagram takipçi satın al diye google de arayarak
    takip2018 den takipçi alabilirsiniz


  4. Türk takipçi Satın Al işlemi ne kadar önemlidir?

    Instagram takipçi satın almak önemlidir tabiki de bu
    durumda aktif olmaları ayrıca TÜRK takipçi olmasını isteriz.

    Yılların verdiği tecrübeye dayanarak size en iyi önerebileceğimiz site türk takipçi satın al konusunda uzman kadrosu ile takip 2018′ dir
    Türk takipçi paketlerini incelemek için siteyi ziyaret etmekten çekinmeyiniz.

  5. Hi there, just became alert to your blog through Google, and found that it’s truly informative.
    I am going to watch out for brussels. I’ll be grateful if you continue this in future.

    Lots of people will be benefited from your writing.

  6. However, today it is no longer only a luxury for your extremely wealthy.
    As mentioned earlier, the BLS says that the massage market is projected to improve its variety of practitioners by 19% as much as 2018.
    This robotic massage chair provides you using the
    most comprehensive massage experience with one of the high-end loungers.

  7. However, today go for longer merely a luxury to the extremely wealthy.
    This can help regulate your hypertension and bring it with a normal
    level. These factors can be a life-changing injury
    if the career depends upon your fitness level or becoming in your feet
    for prolonged periods.

  8. There are many approaches to start finding your true self, info is as simple as connecting on your own physically through self-massage.
    This means that this man doesn’t want or have to go to sleep
    after sex. However, if you utilize tall clients or clients of varying
    height and size, you might appreciate a massage table that is certainly
    more than that is a standard.

  9. There are many solutions to go about finding your true self,
    one ofthese is actually connecting with yourself physically through self-massage.
    This can help regulate your blood pressure and produce it with a normal level.
    Massage recliner units are excellent ways to deviate from
    the sedentary lifestyle.

  10. I’m now not certain where you’re getting your info, but great topic.
    I needs to spend some time learning much more or understanding more.
    Thanks for wonderful information I was on the lookout for this info for my mission.

  11. Güvenilir Takipçi Satın Alınabilir Site
    en iyi siteden takipçi al seçenekleri bireylerin beklentilerine göre çok çok detaylı olabilmektedir.

    Herkesin Instagrama hesabında değişik bir gaye ve beklentiyle takipçi miktarını çoğaltmak istemesi söz konusudur.

    Bunların hepsine hitap edebilecek hizmetlerin sunulması ile
    birlikte en iyi Takipçi Satın Al sitesinden takipçi almaktır.

    Site üzerinden 1.000, 2.000 bu rakamların fazlası
    yada azı dilediğiniz kadar en iyi siteden takipçi alabilirsiniz

  12. Instagram da artık basit bir halde fenomen olabilirsiniz.
    Takipçilerinizi hızlı ve etken bir şekilde arttırmak istiyor
    musunuz? hemen bu siteye giriş yaparak tüm takipçi hizmetlerinden hızlı
    bir şekilde faydalanabilirsiniz. Sizlere en kaliteli takipçi sistemlerini sunarak, kısa vakit arasında istediğiniz kadar takipçi gönderimi yapıyor.
    Sitede yer alan İnstagram takipçi Satın Al hizmetinden faydalanarak arzu ettiğiniz kadar takipçiye ulaşabilirsiniz.

  13. Instagram hesabınızı büyütmek ve yeni müşteriler yada
    sahip olmak için çok fazla düşünmenize kesinlikle gerek yoktur.

    Geri takipler ile uğraşmak yerine hemen takip2018.com a giderek
    Takipci Satin Al
    işleminizi kolayca halledebilirsiniz
    Fenomen ve populer bir kişi olmak için hemen siteyi ziyaret et

  14. Bizler antalya firması olarak çalışmalarımıza yön veren izolasyon uygulamaları ile siz müşterilerimize en iyi izolasyon uygulamaları yapabilmek adına en kaliteli çatı izolasyon ustaları, ile sizlere hizmet vermekteyiz.
    Çatıcı, olarak günümüzde yapmış olduğumuz yalıtım uygulamaları sayesinde müşteri memnuniyetini kazanmış ve kalitesinden asla ödün vermemiş Babadağ çatı, asla düzenini bozmadan izolasyon uygulamasına devam etmektedir.

    antalya izolasyon

  15. Tr Medya sitesi aracılığı ile istediğiniz sayılarda instagram takipçisi satın alabilirsiniz.
    Bu satın alma işlemini yaparken hazırlanmış olan takipçi paketlerinden istediğinizi seçebilirsiniz.
    Her zaman en uygun fiyatların sunulduğu takipçi paketlerinden her biri
    her bütçeye uygun olarak hazırlanıyor. Bütçenize ve ihtiyacınıza en uygun olan paketleri seçebilirsiniz.

  16. Instagram Beğeni Almak Güvenlimi? Takipçi ve Beğeni İşlemleri
    Size Neler Kazandırır

    instagram beğeni satın al işlemi son derece kolaydır.
    Beğeni almak, kişilerin erişimini daha çok arttırmaktadır.
    Kişileri takip etmek, beğenmek ve sürekli etken olmak İnstagram hesabınızın tanıtımını yapabileceğiniz en kolay yollardan biridir.
    sadece takipçi beklemek genel hatlarıyla uzun süren bir durumdur.
    Bundan dolayı kişiler, İnstagram için takipçi ve beğeni
    satın alabilirler.

    Takipçi ve Beğeni Satın Almanın Yararları nelerdir?

    Şüphesiz Instagram takipçi yada beğeni almanın faydaları oldukça fazladır, Özellikle şirketler, butikler, yani internet üzerinden satış yapmak
    isteyen her işletme için lazım olan
    günümüzün kaçınılmaz bir faydası olmaktadır.
    Kişiler bu sayede zahmetsiz bir halde, hesaplarını daha büyük bir hale getirebilirler.
    Takipçi ve beğeni satın almanın faydalarından biri ise kişilerin herhangi bir şekilde birini burun kıvırmadan, takip
    etmeden kolayca bu işlemi yapabilmesidir. Bu satın alma işlemi sayesinde kişiler hiçbir
    şekilde uğraşmadan hesaplarını naturel bir halde büyütebilirler.
    Bu sayede kişiler takipçilerini arttırabilir ve hesaplarını
    belirli bir düzeye çekebilirler.
    http://tiny.cc/begenisatinal !

    takip2018.com ile türk ve gerçek beğeniler satın al

  17. Woah! I’m really enjoying the template/theme of this site.
    It’s simple, yet effective. A lot of times it’s very hard to get that “perfect balance” between user friendliness and visual appeal.

    I must say that you’ve done a amazing job with this.
    Additionally, the blog loads very quick for me on Firefox.

    Excellent Blog!

  18. It was extremely helpful to me. I understood lots of points when I saw your message. Thanks significantly. This was what I have actually been seeking online for a long period of time. I will certainly always remember the assistance I obtained from you. Can I talk with you in even more information possibly? Please call me via my site.

  19. Heya i’m for the first time here. I came across this board and I to find It really helpful & it helped me out much. I am hoping to present something again and help others like you aided me.

  20. Hey there! I just wanted to ask if you ever have any issues with hackers?
    My last blog (wordpress) was hacked and I ended up losing many months of hard work due to no back up.
    Do you have any methods to stop hackers?

  21. It’s appropriate time to make some plans for the future and it is time to be happy. I have read this post and if I could I wish to suggest you few interesting things or suggestions. Perhaps you could write next articles referring to this article. I desire to read more things about it!

  22. Hi there! Someone in my Myspace group shared this site with us so I came to check it out. I’m definitely loving the information. I’m book-marking and will be tweeting this to my followers! Exceptional blog and great design and style.

  23. Hello there I am so glad I found your blog page, I really
    found you by error, while I was browsing on Aol for something else, Regardless I
    am here now and would just like to say cheers for a marvelous
    post and a all round thrilling blog (I also love the theme/design), I don’t have
    time to read it all at the moment but I have bookmarked it and also
    added your RSS feeds, so when I have time I will be back to read much more, Please do keep up the
    excellent job.

  24. Do you mind if I quote a few of your posts as long as I provide credit and sources back to your site?
    My blog site is in the very same area of interest as yours
    and my users would really benefit from a lot of the information you present here.
    Please let me know if this ok with you. Thank you!

  25. It is really a great and useful piece of information. I am happy that you shared this useful info with us. Please stay us up to date like this. Thank you for sharing.

  26. I feel that is among the most important info for me.
    And i am happy reading your article. But wanna commentary on some normal
    issues, The website taste is wonderful, the articles
    is in point of fact great : D. Excellent activity, cheers

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *